Skip to main content

Citizen Kane, and the Problem with Film Ranking

            In 1939 theatre and radio star Orson Welles was offered a generous contract by RKO pictures to bring his talents to Hollywood. This contract called for him to write, direct, produce, cast, and star in two films, and promised him complete creative control over the films’ final cut. Giving such a munificent contract to an untested director was a great risk; especially as the film he made was a hit piece on William Randolph Hearst, America’s biggest media mogul. Hearst met the completed film with fury, and he did everything in his power to prevent the film from becoming commercially successful by pulling all advertising for it and all other RKO pictures. Still, try as he might, Hearst could not bury such an achievement; Citizen Kane captured audiences, and is now widely considered the greatest film of all time.
            Citizen Kane, like Birth of a Nation before it, brought together all the possibilities of cinema and forever changed the rules of the game. Kane’s technical achievements in photography, make-up, set design, music, and editing upped the ante for what subsequent films had to aspire to. Hearst might have been able to marshal the extras unions to prevent Welles from winning the Best Picture, Best Director, and Best Actor Oscars, but Kane was too big to be ignored, and made an immediate impact across the film world.
            Starting in the late 1950s, when the arrival of television meant that it was rediscovered by mass audiences, many have widely and repeatedly asserted that Citizen Kane is the greatest film of all time. The film was number one on Sight and Sound magazine’s great films list from 1962-2002, pushed down to the number two spot in 2012 by Hitchcock’s Vertigo. In 1998 and again 2007, the American Film Institute also declared Kane the greatest film of all time. Roger Ebert called it the greatest film of all time, and also his favourite film. Around the world, several other critics, magazines, filmmakers, and fans have repeated this sentiment, to the point that it is now hard to argue otherwise – Citizen Kane simply is the all time greatest movie.
           
           There is no doubt, therefore, that it is a very, very great movie, and for the purposes of not having to endlessly debate the question, it provides a neat and tidy stock answer. Let Kane be considered the best, just so we don’t have to argue about it, because ultimately, what does it matter if it is or it isn’t? If another film strikes you deeper, hits you on a gut level and changes the way you interact with cinema, yourself, and the world, why can’t you simply decide that that film is the greatest? In the end the idea of greatest is all subjective. I believe that Citizen Kane is great, I will even accept that it is the greatest of all time, whatever that means, but that doesn’t mean it is my favourite film. That honour goes to It’s A Wonderful Life, because I view George Bailey as the model citizen whom all of us should aspire to be like, and because of the ineffable emotional qualities that bring tears of happiness to my eyes on every viewing. For all of its grandeur, for all of its beauty, art, magic, depth and tragedy, for all of the esteem and admiration I have for Welles, Kane falls short on my favourite films list, which, in the end, is the most important film list to me. Citizen Kane should and will continued to be studied, admired, and loved, and for whatever its worth, it can keep the title of cinema’s greatest film, at least for all the influence it has had over the medium. The rest of us will continue to decide what we think is the greatest. 

*  *  *

       One final post script about Orson Welles, who was forced to pay the price for his daring vision; after Citizen Kane, the twenty-five year old was seen as a liability by studios, which reneged on the final cut privileges and the next year mutilated his sophomore effort, The Magnificent Ambersons. Welles had always been aware of his extraordinary talent, and this awareness gained him a reputation as arrogant and hard to work with. Never again would Welles be able to make films with the artistic freedom and studio funds that he had with Kane; although he managed to self finance a few great works, one mourns the fact that he was from then on always stifled in his potential.             
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

South Africa: A Study of History and Film

                                   For a long time now I have had a fascination with South Africa. I cannot say if it is through knowing South Africans, through taking two college courses that focused on South Africa, or just a natural interest aroused by the idiosyncratic nature of the country. The parallels between South Africa and America are well documented – as Robert Kennedy said in 1968, both can be described as a land settled by the Dutch in the mid-seventeenth century, then taken over by the British, and at last independent; a land in which the native inhabitants were at first subdued, but relations with whom remain a problem to this day; a land which defined itself on a hostile frontier; a land which has tamed rich natural resources through the energetic application of modern technology; a land which once imported slaves, and now must struggle to wipe out the last traces of th...
1 comment
Read more

The First Black Movie Star

               Perhaps the title here is a bit controversial. Hattie McDaniel was the first black person to win an Oscar, for her turn as the caricatured “Mammy” in Gone with the Wind (1939), and Stepin Fetchit rode the “Laziest Man in the World” character to stardom in the early days of Hollywood. Still, the case for this sobriquet I believe is strongest made for the actor and singer Paul Robeson.           Robeson was always more of a personality than an actor. Whether he was playing Othello, an Africa warlord, or a day labourer, he was always recognizably himself - he never lost himself in characters in the way that we consider “acting”. With his 6’3 height and athletic build, he was always instantly recognisable - to say nothing of his distinctive voice, a rich bass baritone that has often been imitated, but never equaled by subsequent performers. Despite not being a classically trained actor, it was throug...
Post a Comment
Read more

Skate Movies

      I was never a skater - I was much too uncoordinated. My few misadventures on a skateboard were enough to convince me that it wasn’t for me. Some of my friends were pretty good at it, but I was happy enough to watch. I did, however, spend countless hours on the Tony Hawk's Pro Skater video games. I still have a weird sense of pride for how good I was at them - I might not have been a stellar student, but I could rack up millions of points through calculated button mashing. These games introduced me not only to skateboarding, but also to bands such as the Dead Kennedys, Bad Religion, Suicidal Tendencies, Rage Against the Machine, and many other bands that became staples in my high school CD collection. So, despite never landing a kickflip, I get nostalgic when I see people skateboarding. That nostalgia has led me to check out a few movies that are about skateboarding. I say they are “about skateboarding”, but what I have found is that they are...
Post a Comment
Read more